Dining Options
Below is an evolving list of some of our favorite restaurants in Hampton Bays and Southampton area.
Most restaurants in Hampton Bays are pretty casual and family friendly, including restaurants with full bars and live music.
Southampton tends to be a little more “upscale” with some classic, old-school casual eateries as well.
“Walkable” (under 1 mile)
Whale’s Tale, 78 Foster Ave, Hampton Bays 631-253‑8717
Bright, breezy taco-and-cocktail joint (.7 mile away) with plentiful outdoor seating. Granted, the outdoor seating is on a large parking lot, but it sits next to a marina and canal (parallel to our own Penny Lane canal.) Creative tacos, fresh raw bar offerings, and frozen drinks — perfect for casual evenings and sunny weekends.
The Station Bar, 22 Shinnecock Road, Hampton Bays 631-728-6116
The Station Bar is just down the street .3 miles to be exact on Shinnecock Road. A local institution, it’s known for happy hours from 3-6 p.m., live music, bingo and trivia nights, fresh seafood, burgers, wings and an overall chill vibe. They also have a retail shop called Station Fish and Paddle, that will include water sport rentals, bait & tackle and fishing boat rentals.
Hampton Coffee Company, 31 Shinnecock Rd, Hampton Bays 631-594-1695
Located literally a half a block away, just down Penny Lane at Shinnecock Road, it’s a local café serving small-batch craft coffee, espresso drinks, breakfast sandwiches, burritos, paninis, and fresh-baked pastries. Casual vibe and friendly service.
Amalfi, 32 Lighthouse Road, Hampton Bays Reservations 631-594-2552
This one is .8 mile from The Drake, so you could walk, which might be a good idea, because parking is limited and they rely on a valet system, which can take a while. The food is fine, but it’s the waterfront location and outdoor seating that really shines, with a fun, Italian-seaside resort vibe. Great for a sunset drink. Open for lunch and dinner.
Lighthouse Seafood Raw Bar, 36 Lighthouse Road, Hampton Bays 631-728-5186
9/10 of a mile from The Drake, just before the Ponquogue Bridge to the beach, this is mainly a takeout seafood market. BUT … on Friday through Monday, they have a cute raw bar set up, right on the water so you’re getting the “catch of the day” practically off the boat. Hours are Friday 12-6, Saturdays 12-7, Sunday 12-6 and Monday 12-5 for raw bar, seafood sandwiches and baskets and some non-seafood offerings as well.
Casual/Family
DeRo’s Food & Family, 149 W. Montauk Hwy., Hampton Bays 631-594‑3379
Casual eatery serves a large menu of American and Italian comfort foods — from breakfast and brunch to hearty dinner entrees. Great for families and big appetites.
Francesca’s Pizza & Restaurant, 9 Ponquogue Ave, Hampton Bays 631-728‑8979
Longtime local favorite. Classic Italian-American fare like gourmet pizzas, baked pasta dishes, chicken parm heroes, and homemade ice cream. Casual, family-friendly setting.
Edgewater, 295 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays 631-723-2323
Located east of the Shinnecock Canal in the village of Hampton Bays, Edgewater Restaurant offers an array of Italian fare, seafood dishes, sizzling steaks & gourmet pizzas. You can dine on the deck overlooking Shinnecock Bay, or inside.
Seafood / Waterfront
Canal Cafe, 44 Newtown Road, Hampton Bays 631- 723‑2155
Local favorite hidden along the Shinnecock Canal, known for casual, open-air dining and the best lobster roll in town. Also serves salads, non-seafood options like a great burger, and full bar with a dockside breeze. No reservations but they have plenty of outdoor seating where you can grab a drink and wait for your table.
Cowfish, 58 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays 631-594‑3868
Laid-back yet polished waterfront restaurant known for its American steak and seafood dishes, scenic bay views, large outdoor bar, and family-friendly features like a kids’ menu and play area. Brunch is a highlight.
Sundays on the Bay, 369 Dune Road, Hampton Bays 631-728‑2611
Year-round seafood spot with outdoor and indoor seating, dune and marina views, and a lively yet relaxed vibe. Known for oysters, lobster rolls, and beachy cocktails — ideal for a sunset meal.
Oakland’s Restaurant & Marina 373 Dune Road, Hampton Bays 631-728‑6900
Bustling seafood and steakhouse located on the docks with a nautical vibe and big portions. Popular for both locals and visitors looking for hearty fare in a relaxed setting.
Dockers Waterside Marina & Restaurant, 94 Dune Road, East Quogue 631-653-0653
Stylish marina-side venue known for fresh seafood, steaks, lobster, vibrant cocktails, and live music. Popular for group gatherings and sunset dinners on the deck. The outdoor area is served by a food truck with market price lobster rolls, etc.
Deli/Bagels
Bagel Place Cafe & Deli 40 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, NY 11946 631-723-1264
Local bagel shop and deli with the usual breakfast and lunch offerings.
Katrinka’s Deli, 150 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, 631-728-1441
Classic deli offering made-to-order breakfast and lunch sandwiches, soups, chili, and salads. Known for its daily specials and no-frills, hometown charm.
Fancier/Date Night
Note: Most of these restaurants have steeper prices, but that’s generally the case in Southampton.
Canoe Place Inn, 239 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays Reservations 631-763‑6300
Elegant, historic inn offering refined seasonal menus, garden-side terrace dining, and a cozy tavern atmosphere. Ideal for special occasions or romantic evenings.
Dopo Argento, 15 Main St, Southampton Reservations 631-488-1300
High-end scene-y Italian with a cute outdoor space. Prices are steep.
75 Main, 75 Main St, Southampton Reservations 631-283‑7575
Contemporary American with Italian and Mediterranean influences. Casual‑elegant, with a light, airy interior of dark woods, white linens, and typically lively energy. Dining al fresco on the sidewalk patio is attractive for people‑watching and warm-weather socializing. Comes alive in the evenings—with DJs spinning Thursdays to Saturdays—adding a nightclub/lounge atmosphere.
San Ambroeus Southampton 30 Main St, Southampton Reservations 631-283‑1233
A refined Italian eatery at 30 Main Street, nestled in the heart of Southampton Village. Originating from Milan in 1936, the Southampton location opened in 1992. Refined yet casual‑elegant: white‑tablecloth dining room featuring linen curtains, leather banquettes, wood paneling, and striped chairs. Authentic and classic.
Calissa, 1020 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill Reservations 631-500-9292
Their website says it’s “Mykonos in the Hamptons” and it comes pretty close, especially if you sit outside. A “scene” with authentic Greek food.