Fancier/Date Night

Canoe Place Inn / Good Ground Tavern & The Terrace
Elegant, historic inn offering refined seasonal menus, garden-side terrace dining, and a cozy tavern atmosphere. Ideal for special occasions or romantic evenings.

Mexican

El Mariachi, 122 E. Montauk Hwy., Hampton Bays
Authentic Mexican eatery offering a wide variety of traditional dishes including tacos, burritos, enchiladas, and huaraches. Known for its warm atmosphere, generous portions, and excellent margaritas.

Family Dining

DeRo’s Food & Family, 149 W. Montauk Hwy., Hampton Bays
A newer spot from the DeRobertis brothers, this casual eatery serves a large menu of American and Italian comfort foods — from breakfast and brunch to hearty dinner entrees. Great for families and big appetites.

Francesca’s Pizza & Restaurant, 9 Ponquogue Ave., Hampton Bays
A longtime local favorite serving classic Italian-American fare like gourmet pizzas, baked pasta dishes, chicken parm heroes, and homemade ice cream. Casual, family-friendly setting.

Whale’s Tale, 78 Foster Ave. Hampton Bays

Casual

Cowfish
A laid-back yet polished waterfront restaurant known for its American steak and seafood dishes, scenic bay views, large outdoor bar, and family-friendly features like a kids’ menu and play area. Brunch is a highlight.

Whale’s Tale
Bright, breezy taco-and-cocktail joint with a festive waterfront setting. Enjoy creative tacos, fresh raw bar offerings, and frozen drinks near the fire pit — perfect for casual evenings and sunny weekends.

Seafood / Waterfront

Dockers Waterside Marina & Restaurant
A stylish marina-side venue known for fresh seafood, steaks, lobster, vibrant cocktails, and live music. Popular for group gatherings and sunset dinners on the deck.

Sundays on the Bay
Year-round seafood spot with outdoor and indoor seating, dune and marina views, and a lively yet relaxed vibe. Known for oysters, lobster rolls, and beachy cocktails — ideal for a sunset meal.

Oakland’s Restaurant & Marina
Bustling seafood and steakhouse located on the docks with a nautical vibe and big portions. Popular for both locals and visitors looking for hearty fare in a relaxed setting.

Canal Cafe
A local favorite hidden along the Shinnecock Canal, known for its casual, open-air dining and the best lobster roll in town. Also serves salads, seafood baskets, and beer/wine with a dockside breeze.

Coffee / Breakfast / Sandwiches

Hampton Coffee Company
Beloved local café serving small-batch craft coffee, espresso drinks, breakfast sandwiches, burritos, paninis, and fresh-baked pastries. Casual vibe and friendly service make it a great morning stop.

Katrinka’s Deli
A classic deli offering made-to-order breakfast and lunch sandwiches, soups, chili, and salads. Known for its daily specials and no-frills, hometown charm.